tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post4788684191859462347..comments2023-11-17T03:55:40.736-05:00Comments on Ink Spots: Ahmed Rashid Column on "How to End the War in Afghanistan"Lilhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/18373158801523577733noreply@blogger.comBlogger13125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-83888003062937980342010-02-05T17:07:43.882-05:002010-02-05T17:07:43.882-05:00MK,
My question was rhetorical, though my point wa...MK,<br />My question was rhetorical, though my point was probably not clear. I merely posed the question because it seems to be an alternative that nobody has seriously pondered. (No, I'm not looking to rehash the debate or re-explain in the comments of this thread... but if you're looking for a topic for an upcoming thread...)Schmedlaphttp://www.schmedlap.com/weblognoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-90546592874244414392010-02-05T09:19:35.203-05:002010-02-05T09:19:35.203-05:00Mike--have to agree with MK on panacea but otherwi...Mike--have to agree with MK on panacea but otherwise, agreed.Lilhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18373158801523577733noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-30875886553116333282010-02-04T11:11:38.920-05:002010-02-04T11:11:38.920-05:00MK-
Yeah, panacea is too strong of a word. I nee...MK-<br /><br />Yeah, panacea is too strong of a word. I need to get a new dictionary :).MikeFnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-43389645774806106792010-02-04T10:44:48.870-05:002010-02-04T10:44:48.870-05:00In some cases, the application of violene is the p...<i>In some cases, the application of violene is the panacea that secures the populace in the long term.</i><br /><br />Mike - I'd differ with you slightly, and suggest that violence sets the conditions to secure the populace in the long term. It's a necessary but insufficient element.MKhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09101668944584403261noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-52551723908456692092010-02-04T10:42:49.549-05:002010-02-04T10:42:49.549-05:00Gulliver - well, you know I am among the 'some...Gulliver - well, you know I am among the 'some', and just because you didn't find my arguments convincing doesn't mean they weren't clear.MKhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09101668944584403261noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-66146248410842587172010-02-04T10:15:27.211-05:002010-02-04T10:15:27.211-05:00Lil-
I think one very important point that the au...Lil-<br /><br />I think one very important point that the author missed is timing of negotiations. In a tribal society, at least in my experience, the conversation is less about the words and more about your position of power. <br /><br />The Taliban is stepping up the war this year. Casualties will rise. If we attempt to negotiate during a perceived period of weakness, then the treaties will likely not hold or be very unfavorable towards US national security interest.<br /><br />On the other hand, if we have success during the Surge of demonstrating levels of violence to disrupt/destroy significant guerilla infrastructure, training camps, supply lines, etc..., then we may get the Taliban to come to the table a bit humbled. <br /><br />In some cases, the application of violene is the panacea that secures the populace in the long term. This may be one of those cases. If not, then we could face perpetual war in that land.<br /><br />Thoughts?MikeFnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-5982264632813307452010-02-04T09:36:20.720-05:002010-02-04T09:36:20.720-05:00Because the uncertain risks of leaving outweigh th...<em>Because the uncertain risks of leaving outweigh the uncertain risks of staying.</em><br /><br />In the minds of some, and for reasons that they haven't articulated in a very clear or convincing fashion. Don't forget that part.Gulliverhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12558335790019565924noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-21106995541841425602010-02-04T09:30:45.468-05:002010-02-04T09:30:45.468-05:00Because the uncertain risks of leaving outweigh th...Because the uncertain risks of leaving outweigh the uncertain risks of staying. I presume your question is mostly rhetorical and you don't want to rehash the entire debate.MKhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09101668944584403261noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-14955569528058393622010-02-03T23:49:31.339-05:002010-02-03T23:49:31.339-05:00Win which war? The war between ISAF and the Taliba...Win which war? The war between ISAF and the Taliban? Here's a novel approach to ending that war: leave.<br /><br />Why are we there?Schmedlaphttp://www.schmedlap.com/weblognoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-67795535061270036072010-02-03T12:46:44.884-05:002010-02-03T12:46:44.884-05:00Gulliver,this is what I was getting at with disjoi...Gulliver,this is what I was getting at with disjointed. I understand the desire to mention many things but I thought the column ended up not saying much at all. For example, accountability is pretty straightforward. Building accountability has implications ranging from the constitutional and legal to the procedural and bureaucratic. Within these categories, again, there are pretty clear ways to build accountability. My impression though is that what's difficult is figuring out the small steps that are required on a daily basis to achieve accountability on these different levels in each particular context.Lilhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18373158801523577733noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-28788613844840904722010-02-03T11:02:55.633-05:002010-02-03T11:02:55.633-05:00Nato's job in this surge of commitment is to m...<em>Nato's job in this surge of commitment is to make sure that the Afghans do not just increase their dependency on the West, but actually take charge, become responsible and make themselves accountable for their actions.</em><br /><br />Oh wait, THAT's all we have to do? Shit, why didn't we think of that before now?!Gulliverhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12558335790019565924noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-21593016769551855022010-02-03T09:19:29.548-05:002010-02-03T09:19:29.548-05:00ADTS--nice to see you here!
Agreed. There's ...ADTS--nice to see you here! <br /><br />Agreed. There's a lot in there but every time he started getting somewhere, it seemed like he was being yanked to something else. Maybe the BBC couldn't convince him to do a series.Lilhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18373158801523577733noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8755035051021414780.post-1524642717495808392010-02-03T04:51:26.855-05:002010-02-03T04:51:26.855-05:00Lil:
To be curt, yes, disjointed, although I thin...Lil:<br /><br />To be curt, yes, disjointed, although I think Rashid has the ability of a talented journalist - and displays it here - to turn it, if ever so barely, into a coherent article. Basically, each section of Rashid's article could be an article unto itself. I don't know if space constraints or something else forced him to compress his writing. But within the compact piece are a lot of ideas, even if they are, indeed, disjointed.<br />ADTSADTSnoreply@blogger.com